Electoral College

Lifetime All-Time Electoral College Votes

There have been 57 Electoral Colleges. 4 occurred under the old system (prior to the ratification of the 12th Amendment) where there was no separate ballot for President and Vice-President. Of those 4, one of them (in 1800) operated de facto under the new system.

In the 4 elections of the old system, there were 954 total votes made. In the 53 elections of the new system, there have been 44,996 total votes available (22,498 each for President and Vice-President). 18 of those votes were not made and/or counted (10 for President and 8 for Vice-President) for various reasons in 6 elections:

In 1820, 3 votes for Pres and 3 votes for a VP weren't made because the electors (1 each from MS, PA, and TN) died before the College met.
In 1824, 1 vote for VP was not done for reasons I haven't found yet.
In 1832, 2 votes for Pres and 2 votes for VP weren't made from 2 electors from MD.
In 1864, 1 vote for Pres and 1 vote for VP weren't made; an elector from NV (A. S. Peck) died between the November election and the December electoral college vote (thanks to Paul McClintock for this info).
In 1872, 3 votes for Pres weren't counted, as they were for the deceased presidential candidate Horace Greeley.
In 2000, 1 vote each for Pres and VP wasn't made, by an elector from DC, as a protest against lack of voting representation in Congress.

In addition of course there have been several so-called faithless electors. Among those:

In 1972, Roger MacBride from Virginia voted for the Libertarian Party ticket of John Hospers and Toni Nathan. This makes Toni Nathan the first woman to receive an electoral vote, not Geraldine Ferraro (thanks to Dallas Hays for this info).
In 2004, the absolute number of votes is correct, but one elector from Minnesota voted for John Edwards for both President and Vice-President.

186 men and 3 women have received electoral votes under the new system. 21 men and 0 women received electoral votes under the old system. 3 men, Charles Pinckney, Thomas Jefferson, and George Clinton, received votes under both systems. Thus, 207 people have received votes.

Below is the list of all vote-getters with their all-time electoral votes.

Electoral votes by person, 1804 to 2012.

                tot   P    VP   Place
F.D.Roosevelt  2003 1876  127      1
R.M.Nixon      1939 1040  899      2
G.H.Bush       1608  594 1014      3
A.J.Gore       1015  266  749      4T
R.W.Reagan     1015 1015           4T
J.N.Garner      995       995      6
D.D.Eisenhower  899  899           7
S.T.Agnew       821       821      8
L.B.Johnson     789  486  303      9
C.Coolidge      786  382  404     10
W.J.Clinton     749  749          11
H.S.Truman      735  303  432     12
T.Roosevelt     716  424  292     13
W.Wilson        712  712          14T
T.R.Marshall    712       712     14T
B.H.Obama       697  697          16T
J.R.Biden       697       697     16T
H.H.Humphrey    677  191  486     18
G.Cleveland     664  664          19
J.D.Quayle      594       594     20
C.W.Fairbanks   590       590     21
W.McKinley      563  563          22
G.W.Bush        557  557          23T
R.Cheney        557       557     23T
A.Jackson       509  496   13     25
H.C.Hoover      503  503          26T
C.Curtis        503       503     26T
U.S.Grant       500  500          28
W.J.Bryan       493  493          29
H.A.Wallace     449       449     30
T.A.Hendricks   445   42  403     31
A.E.Stevenson   432       432     32
M.van Buren     428  230  198     33
J.Monroe        417  414    3     34
W.G.Harding     404  404          35
D.D.Tompkins    401       401     36
R.J.Dole        400  159  241     37
A.Lincoln       392  392          38
C.G.Dawes       382       382     39
B.Harrison      378  378          40
W.F.Mondale     359   13  346     41
J.C.Calhoun     353       353     42
J.E.Carter      346  346          43
W.H.Taft        329  329          44
J.S.Sherman     321       321     45
W.H.Harrison    307  307          46
J.F.Kennedy     303  303          47T
A.W.Barkely     303       303     47T
T.E.Dewey       288  288          49
H.Wilson        286       286     50
G.Clinton       281    6  275     51T
J.Tyler         281       281     51T
G.A.Hobart      271       271     53
J.I.Lieberman   266       266     54
C.E.Hughes      254  254          55T
F.Pierce        254  254          55T
W.R.King        254       254     55T
J.Madison       253  250    3     58T
J.R.Edwards     253    1  252     58T
J.F.Kerry       251  251          60
J.C.Breckinr.   246   72  174     61
G.R.Ford        240  240          62
L.P.Morton      233       233     63
H.C.Lodge       219       219     64
J.A.Garfield    214  214          65T
C.A.Arthur      214       214     65T
S.Colfax        214       214     65T
A.Johnson       212       212     68
W.M.Romney      206  206          69T
P.D.Ryan        206       206     69T
R.M.Johnson     195       195     71
H.Clay          193  191    2     72
E.Muskie        191       191     73
E.Warren        189       189     74
R.B.Hayes       185  185          75T
W.A.Wheeler     185       185     75T
S.J.Tilden      184  184          77
J.G.Blaine      182  182          78T
J.A.Logan       182       182     78T
H.Hamlin        180       180     80
J.Buchanan      174  174          81
J.S.McCain      173  173          82T
S.H.Palin       173       173     82T
J.K.Polk        171  170    1     84T
M.Fillmore      171    8  163     84T
G.M.Dallas      170       170     86
J.Q.Adams       168  168          87T
A.G.Thurman     168       168     87T
Z.Taylor        163  163          89
A.Stevenson     162  162          90T
T.Jefferson     162  162          90T
J.W.Kern        162       162     90T
J.Kemp          159       159     93
W.S.Hancock     155  155          94T
W.H.English     155       155     94T
A.Sewall        149       149     96
W.Reid          145       145     97
A.B.Parker      140  140          98T
H.G.Davis       140       140     98T
J.W.Davis       136  136         100T
C.W.Bryan       136       136    100T
E.Gerry         131       131    102
J.M.Cox         127  127         103T
L.Cass          127  127         103T
W.O.Bulter      127       127    103T
J.C.Fremont     114  114
W.L.Dayton      114       114
M.S.Dukakis     112  111    1
L.Bentsen       112    1  111
T.Frelinghuysen 105       105
J.W.Bricker      99        99
R.King           95   34   61
D.Clinton        89   89
J.Sparkman       89        89
H.W.Johnson      88        88
A.E.Smith        87   87
J.T.Robinson     87        87
J.Ingersoll      86        86
R.Rush           84        84
W.L.Wilkie       82   82
C.L.McNary       82        82
H.Seymour        80   80
F.P.Blair        80        80
F.Granger        77        77
E.Kefauver       73        73
J.Lane           72        72
B.Gratz Brown    65   18   47
C.C.Pinckney     61   61
B.M.Goldwater    53   52    1
J.S.Thurmond     53   39   14
W.E.Miller       52        52
J.Sergeant       49        49
G.C.Wallace      46   46
C.E.LeMay        46        46
W.Scott          42   42
W.A.Graham       42        42
W.H.Crawford     41   41
J.Bell           39   39
E.Everett        39        39
F.L.Wright       39        39
W.Wilkens        30        30
W.Smith          30        30
N.Sanford        30        30
T.E.Watson       27        27
H.White          26   26
N.Macon          24        24
J.B.Weaver       22   22 
J.G.Field        22        22
J.E.Howard       22        22
G.B.McClellan    21   21
G.H.Pendleton    21        21
G.McGovern       17   17
R.S.Shriver      17        17
H.F.Byrd         15   15
D.Webster        14   14
R.M.LaFollette   13   13
B.K.Wheeler      13        13
G.A.Ferraro      13        13
S.A.Douglas      12   12
H.V.Johnson      12        12
W.P.Mangum       11   11
J.Floyd          11   11
L.W.Tazewell     11        11
H.Lee            11        11
J.Langdon         9         9
A.M.Landon        8    8
F.Knox            8         8
N.M.Butler        8         8
A.Donelson        8         8
R.Stockton        8         8
W.Wirt            7    7
A.Ellmaker        7         7
G.W.Julian        5         5
A.H.Colquitt      5         5
J.Ross            5         5
J.Marshall        4         4
D.Rodney          4         4
R.G.Harper        4         4
J.M.Palmer        3         3
T.E.Bramlette     3         3
C.J.Jenkins       2    2
J.Hospers         1    1
W.B.Jones         1    1
D.Davis           1    1
N.P.Banks         1         1
W.S.Groesbeck     1         1
W.B.Machen        1         1
T.Nathan          1         1
H.Talmadge        1         1
missing          18   10    8
END

Electoral votes by person, old system, 1789-1800.

J.Adams       247
G.Washington  203
T.Jefferson   145
T.Pinkney     123
A.Burr        104 
G.Clinton      60
S.Adams        15
J.Jay          15
O.Ellsworth    11
R.H.Harrison    6
J.Rutledge      6
J.Hancock       4
J.Iredell       3
S.Johnston      2
J.Henry         2
S.Huntington    2
J.Milton        2
J.Armstrong     1
B.Lincoln       1
E.Telfair       1
C.C.Pinckney    1

The number of votes per election has varied of course. Here is the evolution.

Current system:
1964 to 2012: 538 votes for each, 1076 total; 13 elections, 13988 votes.
        1960: 537 votes for each, 1074 total;  1 election,   1074 votes.
1912 to 1956: 531 votes for each, 1062 total; 12 elections, 12744 votes.
        1908: 483 votes for each,  966 total;  1 election,    966 votes.
        1904: 476 votes for each,  952 total;  1 election,    952 votes.
1896 to 1900: 447 votes for each,  894 total;  2 elections,  1788 votes.
        1892: 444 votes for each,  888 total;  1 election,    888 votes.
1884 to 1888: 401 votes for each,  802 total;  2 elections,  1604 votes.
1876 to 1880: 369 votes for each,  738 total;  2 election,   1476 votes.
        1872: 352 votes for each,  704 total;  1 election,    704 votes. 
        1868: 294 votes for each,  588 total;  1 election,    588 votes.
        1864: 234 votes for each,  468 total;  1 election,    468 votes.
        1860: 303 votes for each,  606 total;  1 election,    606 votes.
1852 to 1856: 296 votes for each,  592 total;  2 elections,  1184 votes.
        1848: 290 votes for each,  580 total;  1 election,    580 votes.
        1844: 275 votes for each,  550 total;  1 election,    550 votes.
1836 to 1840: 294 votes for each,  588 total;  2 elections,  1176 votes.
        1832: 288 votes for each,  576 total;  1 election,    576 votes.
1824 to 1828: 261 votes for each,  522 total;  2 elections,  1044 votes.
        1820: 235 votes for each,  470 total;  1 election,    470 votes.
1812 to 1816: 217 votes for each,  434 total;  2 elections,   868 votes.
        1808: 175 votes for each,  350 total;  1 election,    350 votes.
        1804: 176 votes for each,  352 total;  1 election,    352 votes.
                                              53 elections, 44996 votes.

Old system:
1796 to 1800: 276 votes total; 2 elections, 552 votes.
        1792: 264 votes total; 1 election,  264 votes.
        1789: 138 votes total; 1 election,  138 votes.
                               4 elections, 954 votes.